NEW DEALERS
NEW DEALERS
LIFE IS NOT A LOTTERY. NEITHER SHOULD RETIREMENT BE.
Published by Langhorne P. Breedlove
Originally published · Monday, November 9, 2026 · 8:27 AM ET
Last updated · Wednesday, November 11, 2026 · 9:12 PM ET
Congratulations! You worked forty years, helped build a country's wealth, raised children, paid taxes, and contributed to the economy. Your reward should not be a retirement plan consisting of a scratch-off ticket and a reassuring poster about personal responsibility. New Dealers would like a word with whoever approved that benefits package.
We are Mugwumps who ask what people should be able to count on when employment ends, markets crash, wages fail, illness strikes, or old age arrives with astonishing punctuality. Our instinct is to build durable institutions rather than rely on the occasional generous billionaire, fortunate family, or employer with a working conscience.
We are not nostalgic for every 1930s agency or policy. The original New Deal had immense achievements and serious exclusions. Our work is to study what actually provided security, identify who was left out, and see whether its modern replacement—or expansion—can withstand a budget, a constitutional challenge, and an ordinary Tuesday.
We are the social-security-and-public-capacity faction of Mugwumps. A new deal is not merely a large government check. It is a durable bargain: people contribute to their society, and institutions provide protections against risks that individuals cannot always manage alone.
Some of us will favor universal public programs; others will defend social insurance, negotiated employer obligations, or state-federal partnerships. The faction asks what an actual guarantee means, who qualifies, how it is paid for, and whether the promised benefit arrives without applicants needing an advanced degree in hold music.
The Great Depression brought mass unemployment, bank failures, lost savings, collapsing incomes, and widespread insecurity. When Franklin D. Roosevelt took office in March 1933, the federal government confronted a banking emergency and a devastating economic contraction. The New Deal was not one law, one coherent ideology, or a private invention of a president. It was a shifting set of experiments enacted through Congress, federal agencies, states, labor movements, and political conflict. (Sources 01, 02)
Historians often describe New Deal activity through relief for immediate hardship, recovery of economic activity, and reform of institutions that had failed. Work programs, financial rules, labor protections, and social insurance addressed different parts of the emergency. Not all programs succeeded, and some were struck down by courts or abandoned. An emergency response is not immune to evaluation simply because the emergency was real. (Sources 01, 03)
The Banking Act of 1933 created the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, with federal deposit insurance beginning in 1934. Insurance supported depositor confidence after widespread bank suspensions, but it did not guarantee all investments or eliminate the need for supervision. A New Dealer's question is not whether bankers are nice people; it is how ordinary depositors can trust the basic payments system without subsidizing reckless behavior. (Source 04)
The Social Security Act, signed August 14, 1935, created federal old-age insurance and a framework for unemployment compensation and certain forms of public assistance. Its design involved wage and employer taxes, federal-state administration, and eligibility rules. It was not a universal basic income, not comprehensive national health insurance, and not an immediate pension for everyone alive at the time. The details mattered enormously to which people could claim support. (Sources 05, 06)
The National Labor Relations Act of July 1935—also called the Wagner Act—protected forms of private-sector collective organizing and created the NLRB. It emerged amid strikes, employer resistance and sustained worker organizing. Roosevelt signed the law; labor movements and lawmakers did not merely stand in line waiting for permission to receive rights. Its exclusions also mattered, including farmworkers, many domestic workers, supervisors and public employees under distinct legal arrangements. (Source 07)
The Civilian Conservation Corps, Works Progress Administration and related programs employed people on roads, parks, public buildings, conservation and arts projects. They left tangible infrastructure and professional work behind. But eligibility, gender, race, geography, wages, working conditions and local administration varied. Calling every work program a perfect 'job guarantee' would misrepresent both its achievements and its limits. (Sources 01, 08)
The first Social Security system excluded large groups of workers, including agricultural and domestic laborers, occupations employing many Black workers and women. That exclusion had profoundly unequal effects. Scholars dispute the precise mixture of administrative limitations, institutional choices and racial motivations behind specific coverage provisions; a Social Security Administration historical analysis argues that administrative feasibility explains the original old-age insurance exclusions more directly than an intentional effort to exclude Black workers. The exclusion and its effects are established even where motivations remain debated. (Source 09)
Segregation and local discrimination shaped New Deal program delivery. Women frequently encountered limited access to particular jobs and benefits; Indigenous communities faced policies that often presumed federal authority over their lands and governance; Mexican Americans and other workers faced discrimination and coercive repatriation campaigns during the Depression era. Some programs improved people's circumstances while reinforcing existing inequalities. A modern faction should never adopt 'it was better back then' as a substitute for an honest eligibility table. (Sources 08, 09)
The New Deal also did not end the Great Depression on its own. Economic historians debate the effects of specific fiscal and monetary interventions; mobilization for World War II transformed employment and production. The important lesson is not a miracle performed by one administration. It is that institutional design can reshape risk, labor power, savings protection and public capacity—and can fail or exclude people if the design is defective.
The Federal Art Project, a WPA initiative, employed artists and supported murals, posters, photography and other creative work during the Depression. Imagine recognizing that the person painting the mural also has rent due and needs to buy groceries. What an outrageous concept: an artist as a worker! Some New Deal art survives in public buildings and museums today. (Source 10)
Now for the historical correction nobody asked for but everybody needs: the New Deal's alphabet-soup agencies did not all have the same legal status, duration or purpose. Some built dams, some insured deposits, some hired workers, and some regulated markets. Please stop asking the FDIC to fix your bridge. It has a completely different desk.
→ Explore the Vault
What counts as retirement security, unemployment support, healthcare access, education, or housing assistance? Is the program universal, means-tested, earnings-related, contributory, temporary or conditional? New Dealers insist that those questions be answered in plain language. 'We're helping families' is not a policy until you can tell a family whether it qualifies.
Work can provide income, dignity, skills and community. It can also end because of layoffs, illness, disability, caregiving or age. The economic floor must be evaluated for both people earning wages and those temporarily or permanently unable to do so. A labor program that leaves disabled people without support has confused employment with human worth.
Schools, water systems, transit, public lands, broadband and housing need maintenance and competent public administration. Borrowing for useful infrastructure may be prudent when benefits last decades; it may also be wasteful if the project is poorly chosen or financed. A shovel and a commemorative hard hat are not a cost-benefit analysis.
If eligible people cannot understand the website, complete the forms, reach an office, or receive the payment on time, the program is not delivering its promise. Measure successful receipt, delays, wrongful denials, appeal outcomes, fraud control, staffing and actual living conditions. Publish the bad numbers too.
Programs require taxes, contributions, fees, financing, prioritization, or savings elsewhere. New Dealers can argue for public spending while still accepting fiscal constraints. The more durable the promise, the more important realistic demographic, economic, and budget assumptions become. A commitment written in disappearing ink is not social security.
We can learn from Roosevelt, Perkins, labor organizers, conservation workers and the people who administered new programs without proposing to replicate 1935 in a country whose workforce, population, economy and constitutional controversies have changed. Historical inheritance is an obligation to update the instruction manual.
Social Security financing and benefit adequacy; unemployment insurance coverage; disability support; the cost and eligibility rules of public healthcare; labor bargaining; guaranteed or subsidized employment; housing construction and maintenance; vocational training; municipal infrastructure; deposit protection; childcare and care work; and the administrative systems that determine whether people receive what the law promises.
We would also investigate unintended effects: barriers to working or saving, administrative duplication, benefit cliffs, inflation and supply constraints, inequitable eligibility, politicized grant allocation, wasteful procurement, and programs that exist for decades without evidence of the promised outcome. Social protection is an obligation, not an immunity from audit.
Social Security · Pensions · Employment Security · Unemployment Insurance · Universal Healthcare · Disability Benefits · Worker Bargaining · Economic Mobility · Public Housing · Childcare · Vocational Training · Infrastructure · Public Banking · Care Economy · Federal-State Administration · Program Evaluation · Fiscal Sustainability · Equal Access
→ Explore Social Security From Childhood Through Retirement
→ Explore A Good Job Guarantee
→ Explore Modern Worker Voice & Bargaining
→ Explore Safe, Dignified Public Housing
→ Explore Ten-Year Fiscal Accountability
→ Explore Equal Essential Services in the Territories
→ Explore Reform Corporate Charters & Interstate Operations
→ Explore Public Banking & Postal Financial Services
They start with the people producing, harvesting, repairing, caring and teaching. New Dealers study how public institutions protect those workers through unemployment, aging, disability and economic cycles. They may disagree about whether the first solution is higher bargaining power or a public benefit.
They examine institutions and reforms through measurable public outcomes. New Dealers focus on durable social provision. A worthy rights reform can need a new delivery agency; a long-running benefit can still need modernization.
They ask which problems require coordinated national authority. We ask what that authority is supposed to guarantee. They may prefer federal standards with state implementation; we might demand direct administration when fragmented delivery creates gaps.
They examine democratic control of ownership and workplaces. We focus on insurance, jobs, care and institutional continuity. A generous public program does not, by itself, change who owns a factory; ownership reform does not automatically make tomorrow's benefit payment arrive.
→ Explore Democratic Socialists
These factions raise important questions about individual liberty, fiscal limits, institutional change and service continuity. Their challenges help test the design of a public guarantee.
They start with the liberty cost and government coercion inherent in taxation and administration. New Dealers begin with shared economic risks and social guarantees. Their questions about privacy, compulsion and personal choice are essential checks.
They start with fiscal capacity, debt and the discipline of appropriations. We may start with a social need. A responsible promise must eventually pass their budget test—even when they and we dispute what the public should fund.
They are prepared to rebuild failed institutions from the ground up. New Dealers worry about the benefit checks, medical services and jobs that must continue during transition. If demolition is necessary, continuity is a condition, not a sentimental attachment.
They emphasize keeping proven institutions functioning. New Dealers may advocate expanding benefits or eligibility. Our disagreement is whether a change makes a durable program stronger or accidentally endangers its basic promise.
Treats public services as serious commitments, from parks to community programs. The promise counts only when residents can use the result.
As a teacher, she knows the difference between a reassuring brochure and services that people can actually access. She would demand an intelligible benefits booklet.
Understands the value of community support and how a small eligibility rule can leave someone without help. A casserole is kind; a dependable system matters too.
A judge who understands law and family responsibility. His prosperous household also raises the question of whether safeguards work for families without comparable resources.
Looks beyond election cycles to education, environmental care and long-term public commitments. Her proposals still need funding and accountable administration.
Can explain a national initiative but insists on identifying the gap between the announcement and what agencies actually deliver.
Believes national institutions can serve the public, but even a compelling speech needs an appropriation, competent administration and due process.
Knows that healthcare access depends on trained workers, capacity and dependable systems. A coverage card is not an appointment.
Illustrates how poverty, punishment and lost opportunity compound. Social protection must recognize people as more than their worst financial moment.
Her loss of income and care obligations show how quickly insecurity becomes catastrophe. The value of a safety net depends on whether help arrives in time.
New Dealers do not treat government provision as permission for arbitrary eligibility exclusions, surveillance without legal limits, forced labor, institutional discrimination, denial of due process, or indefinite executive rule. Social programs exist to protect people's practical security, not demand gratitude, political conformity or obedience to the office distributing the benefit.
We reject the notion that every 1930s policy deserves revival. Public investment requires democratic authority, procurement integrity, independent audit, protection of individual and collective rights, and opportunities to challenge mistakes. Our goal is material stability subject to constitutional government—not the world's most beautiful bureaucracy with a locked exit.
Define the service or benefit, the population eligible for it, exclusions, time limits and whether it is insurance, assistance, a public service or direct employment. Do not sell universality when the fine print says otherwise.
Publish revenues, contributions, program costs, demographic assumptions, debt exposure and sensitivity to recessions. A promise can be worth funding without pretending it is free.
Specify poverty reduction, income stability, health access, housing security, employment or another measurable target. Explain why this approach is preferable to feasible alternatives.
Audit eligibility and access across disability, age, family structure, race, geography, immigration status where relevant, care responsibilities and forms of employment. Include those whom the historical New Deal excluded.
Name the administering bodies, staffing, technology, delivery standards, privacy protections, adjudication, and independent review. People should be able to correct errors without knowing a senator.
Publish outcome data, administrative costs, service timeliness, fraud findings, unwanted consequences and scheduled review. Change a policy when the evidence changes. Loyalty to a program is not a substitute for results.
→ Explore Mugwumps
→ Explore Mugwump Factions
→ Explore The Five Pillars of Justice
→ Explore The Vault
→ Explore The Proletariat Essays
Source 03 · Library of Congress — The Great Depression and the New Deal, overview and collections.
Source 04 · FDIC — Historical Timeline: Banking Act of 1933 and federal deposit insurance.
Source 05 · National Archives — Social Security Act (1935), text and historical explanation.
Source 07 · National Archives — National Labor Relations Act (1935), collective bargaining and NLRB.
Source 08 · Library of Congress — New Deal and the Arts, federal arts and employment projects.
Source 10 · National Archives — Franklin D. Roosevelt and New Deal Legislation, archival overview.
Source 12 · National Park Service — Civilian Conservation Corps: the CCC and its work.
WE ARE ONE. · E PLURIBUS UNUM.